Rustic Cow Ice Cream Co. Menu

Located in the heart of Pandora, Ohio, the Rustic Cow Ice Cream Co. Menu is a sweet invitation to slow down and savor life’s simple joys. This cozy spot at 417 E Washington St is known for crafting ice cream that tastes like summer memories in a cone. From classic flavors like creamy vanilla bean and rich chocolate fudge to playful options like cookie dough, butter pecan, and seasonal creations, every scoop is made with care and local charm. The menu doesn’t stop there - sundaes piled high with toppings, thick hand-spun milkshakes, and waffle cones baked fresh daily make choosing just one treat nearly impossible. Whether you’re stopping by after dinner, taking a drive through town, or cooling off on a sunny afternoon, Rustic Cow turns dessert into a small-town experience worth savoring.

Cones

Chocolate
$
Vanilla
$
Twist
$

Shakes

Chocolate
$
Vanilla
$
Hot Fudge
$
Cappuccino
$
Chocolate Peanut Butter
$
Chocolate Marshmallow
$
Butterscotch
$
Peanut Butter
$
Oreo
$
Peanut Butter Oreo
$
Strawberry Oreo
$
Grasshopper
$
Mint
$
Peach
$
Blueberry
$
Pineapple
$
Black Raspberry
$
Strawberry
$
Banana
$

Slushes

Strawberry
$
Cherry
$
Orange
$
Grape
$
Strawberry Kiwi
$
Sour Apple
$
Lemon-Lime
$
Blue Raspberry
$
Watermelon
$

Floats

Root Beer
$
Pepsi
$
Dr. Pepper
$
Coke
$
Cherry Coke
$

Sundaes

Hot Fudge
$
Hot Caramel
$
Chocolate
$
Triple Chocolate
$
Peanut Butter
$
Marshmallow
$
Butterscotch
$
Grasshopper
$
Peach
$
Blueberry
$
Cherry
$
Red Raspberry
$
Pineapple
$
Strawberry
$
Black Raspberry
$

Special Sundaes

Turtle
$
Peanut Butter Extreme
$
Butterfinger
$
Hot Fudge
$
Grasshopper
$
M&M's
$
Snickers
$
Reese's Pieces
$
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
$
Oreo
$
Strawberry Oreo
$
Strawberry Crunch
$

Food

Hot Dog
$
Coney Dog
$
Rocket Dog
$
Bratwurst
$
Sloppy Joe
$
Shredded Chicken
$
Bbq Beef
$
Pulled Pork
$
1/3 Lb. Smoked Cheeseburger
$
Loaded Mac & Cheese
$
Hot Subs
$
Ham
$
Combo
$
Pizza
$

Sides

Homemade Mac & Cheese
$
Homemade Green Bean Casserole
$
Coleslaw
$
Chips
$

Flavorburst

Peach Twist
$
Black Cherry
$
Strawberry
$
Butter Pecan
$
Green Apple
$
Tropical Orange
$
Blue Raspberry
$
Cotton Candy
$

Rockets

Cookie Dough
$
Mint Chocolate Chip
$
M&M's
$
Snickers
$
Reese's Pieces
$
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup
$
Oreo
$
Butterfinger
$
Sprinkle
$

Special Rockets

Strawberry Oreo
$
Cookie Monster
$
Banana Split
$

Extras

Pecans
US$75.00
Peanuts
$
Whipped Cream
$

Others

Strawberry Banana
$
Mint Brownie
$
Candy Shoppe
$
Strawberry Shortcake
$
Oreo Supreme
$
Birthday Cake
$
S'mores
$
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 419-384-3344